Language: 
To browser these website, it's necessary to store cookies on your computer.
The cookies contain no personal information, they are required for program control.
  the storage of cookies while browsing this website, on Login and Register.

Author Topic:  Off topic -> Community-driven board(s)  (Read 19084 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Frostyglen

« Reply #30 on: 08, January 2008, 00:15:56 »
Hehe, No Longir, that doesn't sound harsh at all. I know I'm not qualified to mod a board written in portugese(sp?), Sanscrit, or Yittish.

 While I try to stay positive about things, it doesn't stop me from seeing the worst that could happen. It just takes me a few minutes to choke that lil' monster down and see the sunshine.

 Seeing as how I can't see a better alternative ( other than said extra mods ) I'm all for it. I understand that there will be a mod behind the...er, beginner mods...to keep things on an even keel.
It is very dark....you are likely to be eaten by a grue.

Anich

« Reply #31 on: 08, January 2008, 04:30:20 »
Quote from: "ThePlaneskeeper"
Smacky: can you do a combination of 1 and 3?
Quote from: "smacky"
Yes, I will find out more about #2 and #3 (and combining the methods) tonight (unless I don't ;)).
So which combination are we talking about? IMO #2 and #3 are almost the same thing, they are both popularity based. Karma, or poll, which ever way works, combined with #1 sounds like a good flow to me. This way, it's more of a test, to separate the responsible ones from the irresponsibles. People will try to increase their post counts, therefore encouraging them to spam and necropost. But, by doing this they are risking their social reputation, they will lose karma points and not make OT mod. The responsible ones will take their time and build their social reputation - a reasonable OT mod. Although it's quite biased, and it'll probably cause an uproar at first, but whatever the heck ...

Cheers,
Anich
Some of you may remember me in-game as Stcrisis.

smacky

« Reply #32 on: 08, January 2008, 14:18:53 »
Yes, good reasoning Anich. The problem (possibly) is permissions are allocated to a membergroup, not an individual member. While belonging to a particular membergroup can be determined automatically based on post count, I am not sure if karma can affect it. Polls certainly can't.

The difference between karma and polls is that polls are one-vote-per-person whereas I can smite you many times (at a default rate of one smiting per hour). Which means that polls reflect community opinion (if at all) at one particular time, while karma is an ongoing thing. So if at first I vote yes in the 'do we let Anich mod?' poll but subsequently decide you're an idiot, the only way to express this opinion is to start a new poll and vote no. Which, besides spamming, requires everyone else to be interested enough to vote. Which they won't be if polls keep popping up on exactly the same issue. Also, then Frosty puts up his own independent poll on you at the same time. You, bitter and twisted with rage, put up a poll questioning my popularity, and so on. It quickly becomes ludicrous.

With karma these polls become constant and 'invisible'. There is always one poll per person. Anyone can vote on any of them multiple times. So it's still a popularity contest, but at least it is relatively accurate over time and not a cause of spam.

smacky

« Reply #33 on: 27, February 2008, 00:23:19 »
So if I've done this right, on community chat everyone has certain mod privileges based on their post count.

Well, combat dummies and small ants don't.

Giant slimes get the ability to split and merge topics.

Ancient bone dragons can also lock topics and polls.

Lesser moroch avatars can also delete or edit other peoples posts, topics, and polls.

Demonic Priests of Moroch also get a few more moderation privileges, such as being able to post to locked topics.

This only applies to the Community chat forum.

Furthermore, new posts in that forum do not add to your post count. So to get the mod privs you need to post daimonin-related stuff to the other boards.

Also, all moderation actions are logged, so don't abuse it. ;)

subaru

« Reply #34 on: 27, February 2008, 05:07:37 »
wow very nice plan smacky, i love where you have tooken this!

this new system seems to be a giant leep for the OT board, and im sure there will be people to abuse it but it seems like you have that under control as well

let me know if theres anything i can do to help :}

~missy
~*~Whats important is not how you start, but how strong you finish~*~

funny quote from ellwoodblues: "and to keep Subaru from wanting to hunt you down with her specially made "Beating Stick +1 of Kneecaping Double Posters.""


l00natyk

« Reply #35 on: 27, February 2008, 05:24:53 »
Yes! Yes! Where is Ultimajoe? :D

smacky

« Reply #36 on: 27, February 2008, 13:37:02 »
hehe I haven't seen a way to link this to karma yet. AFAICS karma is just for fun.

spyke

« Reply #37 on: 27, February 2008, 13:50:44 »
so im a warlord of moroch army that means i can edit/delete/lock...*thinks of evil things* nah i wont abuse it im not that bad guy :)

l00natyk

« Reply #38 on: 27, February 2008, 16:26:06 »
hehe I haven't seen a way to link this to karma yet. AFAICS karma is just for fun.
Ageree, if karma will do anything else then ppl will just start smiting eachother including MT :D

so im a warlord of moroch army that means i can edit/delete/lock...*thinks of evil things* nah i wont abuse it im not that bad guy :)
I'm working on it too :D I hope i'll catch you soon. For now i'm depressed since after changes i can't edit your posts   :-\

Anich

« Reply #39 on: 29, February 2008, 06:25:58 »
Nicely handled, Smacky.

Cheers,
Anich
Some of you may remember me in-game as Stcrisis.

Nobbit

« Reply #40 on: 29, February 2008, 08:38:11 »
Anich, wth happened to ur avatar?
nobbit
former collector of cursed rings
nowadays collector of cursed things

A dwarf, who fights with a sword does also like diluted beer (dwarvish saying)

Anich

« Reply #41 on: 02, March 2008, 01:44:19 »
Nobbit: lol yeah. There seems to be a small problem with avatar management mentioned here. I recently got my diamond back.

Do Global Mods have all mod privs on CC? Or is it entirely based on post count?

Anich
Some of you may remember me in-game as Stcrisis.

smacky

« Reply #42 on: 02, March 2008, 13:07:27 »
Global mods have all mod privs on cc, but I'd prefer them not to use them unless absolutely necessary. Ie, delete a blatant advert, resolve some problem where community mods get in a petty fight, etc.

Tags:
 

Related Topics

  Subject / Started by Replies Last post
2 Replies
3668 Views
Last post 11, July 2005, 19:46:11
by Unislash
5 Replies
2540 Views
Last post 27, March 2007, 22:36:29
by BertieTheBlue
26 Replies
7285 Views
Last post 03, May 2007, 19:14:36
by Ellwoodblues
8 Replies
5072 Views
Last post 27, October 2007, 00:47:25
by trepie
15 Replies
11523 Views
Last post 20, November 2008, 16:50:53
by Nite_Star